Chidori: Anime vs. Manga!

Eidolon · Post by **Eidolon** » Sun Jun 13, 2004 11:53 pm

Well to solve a little debate with Kelek, I've made this poll.

I feel that Manga Chidori is both more likeable and more developed.

What do YOU have to say?

^___^

EDIT, Erm, posting WHY would be good too.

Kelek · Post by **Kelek** » Sun Jun 13, 2004 11:58 pm

Good idea.
I think the anime Kaname is more developed because she has to develop because of the plot and the action and she grows because of what happens. You can also see her relationship with Sousuke grow and she shows a lot of emotions in the anime.
The manga consists of mostly humorous romance adventures involving Kaname and Sousuke and hardly any other characters.

Eidolon · Post by **Eidolon** » Mon Jun 14, 2004 12:00 am

Thing is though, she still grows just as much in the manga... And we see a lot more of the evolution of her feelings towards Sousuke since we can read her thoughts.

Also, we see a lot more of her other sides than you'd expect. A good example of this being when she punches out Mizuki for making a crack regarding her watch... Earlier, her watch was separate from all her other stuff, instead sitting by the picture of her mother. One can only conclude that that watch was a (graduation?) gift from her mother, hence why it's so important to her - it's one of few things from her mother she has left.

Dannan · Post by **Dannan** » Mon Jun 14, 2004 12:06 am

I like anime kaname because she has the ability to show more emotion. also because the anime develops the characters at a more steady pace. the manga does not allow her to realize her emotions fast enough.

HELLFIRE · Post by **HELLFIRE** » Mon Jun 14, 2004 12:08 am

...she's got a stronger right arm in the anime, I'll give her that

Regards

Sgt. Sagara Sousuke · Post by **Sgt. Sagara Sousuke** » Mon Jun 14, 2004 3:27 am

I've always felt that the anime drawings are slightly better.

Anime Chidori shows the emotional development and there are bits and pieces showing the devopment of Sousuke and Chidori's relationship...

Eidolon · Post by **Eidolon** » Mon Jun 14, 2004 3:33 am

Kelek wrote:she shows a lot of emotions in the anime

Dannan wrote:I like anime kaname because she has the ability to show more emotion

Dannan wrote:. also because the anime develops the characters at a more steady pace.

Dannan wrote:the manga does not allow her to realize her emotions fast enough

Sousuke wrote:I've always felt that the anime drawings are slightly better.

Sousuke wrote:Anime Chidori shows the emotional development

Sousuke wrote:there are bits and pieces showing the devopment of Sousuke and Chidori's relationship...

GOOD LORD PEOPLE, HAVE NONE OF YOU READ THE MANGA?!?! IT HAS ALL OF THOSE!!!

PookaKitten · Post by **PookaKitten** » Mon Jun 14, 2004 3:45 am

As usual, I'm seeing advantages on both sides. (I really wish people would put in a third option - "I like both.")

Anime: The added Homeland Arc adds a new dimension to the relationship between Kaname and Sousuke. You can almost taste her pain and worry when she is walking down the road alone, worrying about Sousuke.

Manga: You get more of a inner look at her mind. I absolutely loved the kidnapping arc, where you saw her reactions to being whispered, and what being whispered actually was. Also, realize that in terms of time span, the manga is not even close to the end of the anime's plot, so there's less time for character development.

Samantha

Teletha Testarosa · Post by **Teletha Testarosa** » Mon Jun 14, 2004 6:11 am

HELLFIRE wrote:...she's got a stronger right arm in the anime, I'll give her that

Regards

true, but she got dual fans in the manga! :p

Post by **Taurec** » Mon Jun 14, 2004 7:50 pm

Both .. just could get my hands on the first 3 vols here in holland ..

Dannan · Post by **Dannan** » Mon Jun 14, 2004 9:04 pm

@Eidolon

yes, yes I have read the manga and no, I refuse to change my stance. the manga development is too slow for my liking. also anime is drawn better haha

Dannan · Post by **Dannan** » Mon Jun 14, 2004 9:12 pm

lol I am so sorry my i.explorer having problems. didn't mean to post same thing twice

Teletha Testarosa · Post by **Teletha Testarosa** » Mon Jun 14, 2004 9:45 pm

Taurec wrote:Both .. just could get my hands on the first 3 vols here in holland ..

send me 30 dollars american money and u'll get 3 sent to u

FullMetal*Panic!

Chidori: Anime vs. Manga!

Which Chidori do you like more / is more developed?

Chidori: Anime vs. Manga!